PickCotton.Com For Straight Talk Advertising and Results.

The best argument for the use of simple truths in advertising is to take a hard look at your bottom line.

Vive la difference!

Wanamaker Quote

Save your scalp!

You can't beat my whip!

Upside for Quayside

Ad suppressed by WSJ

Billboards for sale

Case history list

Heresy or genius ad?

Ahead of my time.

Rent golf balls?

Hope for America

FLY ON AIR FORCE ONE!

Sleep in Lincoln Bedroom

Challenge me.

Contact Cotton

IF YOU CAN'T SELL YOUR GOLF BALLS, WHY NOT RENT THEM?
 AN OUTRAGEOUS THING TO DO! YOU BET IT IS.
AND IT WORKED.
I TOOK THE RISK OUT OF THE PURCHASE.
Case history below.

The ad that took giant balls.
The ad that took giant balls.
Admit it. This took balls. And it worked
Admit it. This took balls. And it worked.

I decided to have a little fun taking the facts of one of my most outrageous case histories (renting golf balls) and writing it up Mickey Spillane style.  It reads like a detective pot boiler, all while dramatizing timeless truths that must be mastered for a client to triumph in the marketplace.  See list of case histories on next page.


      I was ignoring the phone that wouldn't ring for three weeks when it rang. I let my secretary, Roxie; answer it so she would have something to do besides crack her gum.
     "Balls," she said, handing me the phone.
     "Balls" I asked, taking the receiver.
    "That's right," repeated the voice over 2,500 miles of AT&T. ?I've made about a zillion golf balls with a new process and I can't even give em away.?
     Which was a shame because he wanted to sell them in the worst way. The worst way is without a marketing plan with a purpose for buying the ball. The guy was an egghead from Princeton, a plastics engineer from the better mousetrap school of thought. He had made a better golf ball and now it was his creditors beating a path to his door.
     "Can you help me out" pleaded Dr. Calvin Wolf, which was the name of the chemistry whiz guy. "I hear you're a marketing miracle worker."
     "Sure, damn right, I said. "Call me in six months and I'll see what I can do."
    " No. Now. Please, I got enough dough left in the till to fly you to Princeton Chemical Research's New Jersey tomorrow and pay your fee. Take a look at my golf ball factory, talk to my board and convince us that we haven't blown $8 million bucks."
      A day later I was in Princeton watching a Rube Goldberg machine out of Star Wars putting powdered plastic under 700 tons of pressure. Out came a thousand solid golf balls a minute, each of which would out-play and out-last the old wound three-piece rubber golf balls at a tenth of the cost.
    But how do you get golfers, traditionalists and brand loyalists to a fault, to try a new kind of golf ball when you can't get the product into the stores? All I needed to do was pull an ad out of my fundament that would revolutionize the billion-dollar golf ball industry.
      Hours earlier, on the flight over the fruited plain I had an idea so outrageous that it scared me. It had come to me in a gag line from Rowan and Martin?s Laugh-In, a TV comedy show of the 1960s. I don't discuss half-baked ideas with clients. I needed to buy some time.
    "Mr. Cotton, you're our last hope," the Chairman said to me two hours before my red-eye back to L.A. "Do you have anything for us?" 
     "If I think of anything, I said, It'll cost you another round trip ticket and a night at the Marriott."
     I used my 5-hour flight to sketch out the ad that would save PRC and introduce the one-piece golf ball to a skeptical golfing public. Forty-eight hours later I was back in Princeton with finished ads on a covered easel.

 
 “Gentlemen,” I said to the board. “Since you can’t sell your Golf Ball of Tomorrow, you are left with the only way your are going to get them accepted by the golfing public…”
    And with a flourish, I snatched the cover off the easel, explaining: “If you can’t sell them, Rent them!”
    I’ve seen happier pusses on coroners’ juries. For a moment, I thought the board was going to rise, sing a dirge and plunge letter openers into my heart. But there was only silence. A defeated silence. Then more silence. These guys had all the sparkle of dictionary illustrations. A full 25 minutes of silence passed as seven PRC board members stared at a display ad inspired by Goldie Hawn’s observation on Laugh-In that groceries were so expensive that it was a shame you couldn’t rent them.
     That was the pitch: To prove that PRC one-piece golf balls flew straighter, putted truer and lasted longer than the $12 a dozen top of the line golf balls players were now buying, the company would rent a brand new box of 12 golf balls for $2 plus a $5.50 deposit.  Golfers were assured that they could knock the balls all over the course and return them at any time in any condition for their deposit back, pro-rated for lost balls.
     Maybe I wasn’t expecting a ticker tape parade, but 25 minutes of mute staring? The silence was finally broken when somebody - it was me - said:
   “Before you guys remember where you keep the rope, I’m calling Herman’s Sporting Goods. They have seven stores and I know the operations manager.”
The next day I listened to Herman’s ops chief, Len Steinlauf, tell me to save my breath, that Herman’s had tried every promotion known to sell golf balls.
     “Have you tried renting them,” I asked, again whisking the cover off my ad easel.
    The rest is marketing history. Herman’s took 144 dozen-golf balls and ran an ad in the Wall Street Journal on on Saturday. Monday morning Herman’s seven stores were stripped of PCR golf balls and desperately re-ordering.  The manufacturer was poised with more deliveries, and Herman’s rented 5,000 dozen new-fangled one-piece golf balls in three weeks, establishing the one-piece golf ball in one bold, counter-intuitive stroke of marketing history.
     In the first three weeks of the promotion in just two stores, the 5,370 customers who "rented”, only nine returned for their deposit. I’m guessing they didn’t have the balls to return them.
     When I got back to the office I gave Roxie a new PCR golf ball, telling her that she held in her hand the golf ball of the future. Five minutes later she gave it back.
    “Lousiest paper weight ever,” she bitched. “It keeps rolling off my desk.”  
  


        Advertising cannot fail !!!
 Challenge Stan          Contact Cotton

Twitter@cottonstan